Third Way: The New Gold Rush: Insider Trading And Gambling On War

zpagistock

Estimates show the civilian death toll from the Iran war to be over 3,000, according to the Human Rights Activists News Agency (HRANA). As Iranian citizens reel from the horrors of international conflict, what can Americans do? Bet on it and make a quick buck. Prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket let users gamble on real-world outcomes, like the fall of the Iranian regime. As the sites grow in popularity, so do the threats of insider trading and underage gambling, as well as a new grim reality of individuals gambling on events such as wars.

It was a big week for the sites, with U.S. midterms pulling a large number of bettors, as both Kalshi and Polymarket have highlighted tabs labeled either “Politics” or “Elections.” Kalshi alone saw $1.3 billion wagered on midterm elections. 

There are a few differences between the two major sites. For example, Kalshi operates in U.S. dollars and is designated as a Designated Contract Market (DCM) by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), while Polymarket is split into two sections: a crypto-native platform and a U.S.-focused platform. However, betting on both sites generally works the same way. There is no “House,” like in traditional gambling. Instead, bettors trade with each other, purchasing contracts tied to an event's outcome, often listed as Yes or No options. 

Kalshi argues its site fights insider trading because it adheres to federal regulations, unlike other unregulated sites. 

Insider Trading

In May, House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Chairman James Comer launched an investigation into insider trading in the prediction markets. Comer is leading a team to analyze how bad actors may use overseas accounts to trade on nonpublic information, and to evaluate sites like Kalshi and Polymarket's safeguards against individuals' attempts to circumvent federal regulations on betting on the markets. 

In August, U.S. Army soldier Gannon Ken Van Dyke was charged with using classified military information to profit off the capture of former Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro through the prediction markets. According to prosecutors, the Green Beret had a payout of over $400,000 after allegedly placing over a dozen bets on Polymarket related to Maduro’s capture. Van Dyke pushed to have the case tossed, arguing that his wagers were not illegal “swaps,” a financial agreement to exchange money based on real-world events. A New York federal judge declined the motion to dismiss.

The U.S. government even launched investigations into “Iran contract events” after a 60 Minutes report in May regarding suspicious Polymarket accounts betting on Iran-related events with a 98-percent success rate raked in $2.4 million. Another Polymarket trader named “Magamyman” earned $553,000 after betting on joint U.S.-Israeli strikes on Iran. Sen. Chris Murphy accused members of President Donald Trump’s circle of “profiting off war and death.” The White House denied that anyone on Trump’s team was involved.

The fact is, individuals could use their positions to profit from markets, betting on events in which they hold nonpublic information. Amid criticism over Congress members' freedom to trade public stocks, a new avenue for those in power to profit from nonpublic information, like these sites, should be shut down or heavily regulated. According to a Scripps News poll, over 70% of Americans are concerned that individuals could trade on prediction markets using insider knowledge. 63% have little to no confidence that it can be stopped. And frankly, they are probably right.

Underage Gambling

Even if the federal government can crack down on insider trading, it still has to grapple with an explosively popular market where young adults can gamble on sports, elections, and war. A CNN analysis shows that adults under 21, who are barred from gambling in most states, traded around $5.4 billion on Kalshi this year alone. However, because prediction sites are regulated as financial markets, anyone over 18 can access them. 

An 18-year-old die-hard Jets fan cannot bet on his team winning through FanDuel, because sports betting at his age is illegal. He should not fret, though, because he can trade contracts tied to the Jets winning through Kalshi. But obviously, that is not the same as sports betting; he is taking advantage of sports-based trades through a regulated financial market. Obviously. 

As sports betting is on the rise, especially among the youth, these sites normalize gambling on real-world events with serious impacts on real people. When kids can’t access regulated sports betting, they will turn to these sites. They will get curious about the “Politics” section and see that they can bet on the number of deportations in 2026. Those taking the over will be celebrating a big win while ICE raids communities.

Regulations and State battles

Not-so-hot take: Congress is bad at proactive legislation. Whether it's emerging markets like these, or developing technologies like AI, the federal government is always playing catch-up. This is especially noticeable as we transition out of one of the least productive Congresses since the ‘80s. 

Leading up to midterms, Kalshi, Polymarket, and their founders donated around $5 million to Republican and Democratic political groups. However, after a midterm sweep, Democrats have turned their attention to restraining prediction markets. Like everything nowadays, it's become a partisan issue. The Trump administration has stood behind the markets; Don Jr. is even a paid advisor for Kalshi, and his venture capital firm is a major financial supporter of Polymarket.

Many states have had their own battles with companies such as Kalshi and Polymarket. In late October, Utah filed criminal charges against Kalshi and two of its executives; the charges included 13 counts of violating state prohibitions on gambling and another on profiting from illegal activity. Kalshi contends that it is not beholden to state gambling laws. Utah is currently one of 20 states locked in litigation with prediction market websites.

In the future, expect never-ending legal battles of states against Kalshi. Listen to Democrats' promises to rein in the sites, which turn into legislation that always falls just short of a majority vote. Watch Republicans claim Democrats are communist for attempting to deny Americans a free market. Scroll on TikTok to see the 18-year-old Jets fan post get-rich-quick schemes after he makes a pretty penny betting on the Iran war.

Next
Next

Checkpoint: The Flawed Formula of SNAP Accountability