Mideast: Iraq Navigates The Withdrawal Of US-Coalition Forces After Two Decades

Prakash Chavda

Nearly one month into the complete withdrawal of US-led coalition forces from Iraq, the Iraqi government, people, and militias are navigating a new security reality. While American forces and anti-ISIS coalition partners had initially been invited back into Iraq in 2014 to stave off the nation falling under ISIS control, the past 12 years saw the relationship between the different powers at play become increasingly complicated. Now, with the withdrawal of coalition forces ending roughly two decades of foreign military presence, the Iraqi government is contending with the power vacuum left in their wake and the hole it has left in Iraq’s defense infrastructure. 

The history behind foreign forces operating in Iraq, as well as the changing relationships between said foreign forces and the Iraqi military and government, are deeply complex. 

Iraq came under occupation from the United States and its coalition partners in March of 2003, with the supposed justification that Saddam Hussein’s government was developing weapons of mass destruction— a claim that was later proved false. Hussein’s government, which ruled as a Sunni dictatorship, was overthrown, and an American occupation government was established in its place, which banned former members of Hussein’s party from government jobs and dissolved the military, leaving 400,000 Iraqi military men armed and without jobs. Many of these men would go on to join Al-Qaeda, an offshoot of which would ultimately become the group ISIS. 

By 2014, the country, which has an overwhelming Shiite majority, had established a democratic government led by Shiite parties, many of whose leaders had found refuge in Iran — a Shiite theocracy — during the brutal repression of Shiites under Hussein’s regime. By then, foreign forces had largely withdrawn to hand power to the new state, while still maintaining military influence. 

ISIS’s sweeping offensive through western Iraq in 2014, however, and the staggering speed at which the Iraqi military collapsed against them, led to foreign forces being invited back into the country to stave off its collapse. The Iraqi military and foreign anti-ISIS coalition forces — overwhelmingly American — worked together against ISIS, along with Iraqi militias, who were called to fight by the country’s highest Shiite cleric and who became known as the Popular Mobilization Forces. These forces were largely trained and funded by Iran. 

In Iraq’s story, Iran and the United States play significant roles, and both contributed to the ultimate withdrawal of coalition forces that took place in September. 

While ISIS served as a common enemy for the Iraqi military, PMF, and foreign forces, ISIS’s defeat brought their differing ideological tensions to the surface. Many militias within the PMF are anti-American and deeply ideologically aligned with Iran, and while they have been officially integrated into the Iraqi military, they consistently act outside of the control of the Prime Minister, despite him being their official Commander in Chief. 

These tensions came to a head when, following the start of the Israel-Hamas War in 2023, Iran decided to utilize its Axis of Resistance to weaken Israel and its primary ally, the United States, with the hope of forcing a ceasefire. The Iran-aligned militias within the PMF are part of this Axis of Resistance and, as such, launched attacks against American military bases in Iraq. 

Between October 2023 and February 2024, pro-Iran militias within the PMF carried out roughly 190 coordinated drone, rocket, and ballistic missile attacks on American military personnel and bases in both Iraq and Syria. The US military would significantly retaliate after a January 2024 strike on Tower 22 near the Jordan border killed 3 American Army soldiers and wounded over 40 others. 

The strikes the United States carried out in retaliation against militia leaders in Baghdad, Western Iraq, and Eastern Syria would succeed in killing numerous militia leadership targets, but would also force the Iraqi government into a difficult position. While the United States viewed the attack as a necessary means of self-defense against a group of rogue actors the Iraqi government could not control, the Iraqi government viewed the strikes as a violation of Iraq’s sovereignty. 

Facing intense pressure from his governing coalition, Iraqi Prime Minister al-Sudani initiated formal talks in 2024 to end the coalition that had brought foreign forces back into the country in 2014, stating that the presence of American and coalition forces had become a “magnet for instability.” Ultimately, the process of withdrawal was agreed upon and ended on September 30, 2026, with the complete withdrawal of US-led coalition forces from Iraq. 

In the month that has followed, this withdrawal has officially been celebrated throughout the country, with the government marking a four-day national holiday of “Sovereignty Days” culminating with the pre-existing National Day of October 3. Grand military parades took place throughout Baghdad and the holy city of Najaf, and citizens filled the streets waving the Iraqi flag and enjoying festivities and fireworks. Pro-Iran PMF militias celebrated the withdrawal as an important step in reaching their goal of ousting Western influence in the Middle East and framed it as a triumph of the Axis of Resistance. 

But underneath this surface of celebration, greater questions about the stability of Iraqi security — especially its ability to self-defend and control the pro-Iran militias — have loomed large. 

Iraq now faces a serious deficit in its ability to defend itself from the air; before the withdrawal, the United States provided highly advanced anti-missile and counter-drone systems, and without these, Iraq currently has little native capability to intercept low-flying suicide drones or ballistic missiles. While the Iraqi government has turned to Turkey and South Korea to procure these instruments and systems for themselves, it has been estimated that there will be at least a 6-month wait time until these systems arrive and become operational, leaving them highly vulnerable in the meantime. 

Iraq has also been left without the means to effectively track and monitor militants and ISIS, where formerly US thermal and high-altitude drone technology provided them real-time surveillance and the ability to analyze movements, and therefore the ability to quickly and effectively move in response. Already, ISIS has begun taking advantage of the new weak points in Iraq’s defenses, launching a coordinated campaign to step-up attacks and exploiting rural routes and unsurveilled areas to move closer to Baghdad. 

While Iraq had planned that disarming pro-Iran militias would act as a crucial step in maintaining post-withdrawal security, this has been met with fierce opposition and refusal to disarm, bringing further into question the ability of the government to control aspects of its own military. The government was forced to postpone its pro-Iran disarmament plans until mid-2027 as a result. 

The situation Iraq has faced since September, then, is not merely so simple as either simply deciding to be done with foreign forces or easily maintaining its security without them. Instead, Iraq must contend with serious gaps in its defense system, significant disobedience from members of its own military forces, and ongoing threats from hostile groups such as ISIS while dealing with continued historical tensions between its Shiite and Sunni populations.

Previous
Previous

Mideast: Lebanon Prepares For UN Withdrawal from Blue Line Border With Israel

Next
Next

Mideast: Egypt Makes Strides Towards Its Ambitious Desert Reclamation Goal